After much revision and a few rejections, my new cosmology paper has been accepted by Galaxies, a reputable journal. It was subjected to extensive peer review, with more than 30 queries and comments to address, plus typesetter's corrections, but they were all valid points and have produced a much more professional paper than my original version.
The world of academic publishing has turned on its head since I wrote my first paper 11 years ago. Then, papers were published free of charge, with journals recovering their costs by charging university and institution libraries exorbitant reading fees. This cut out non-academics such as myself unless I ordered papers through the local lending library. Fortunately, this period coincided with Edwin being at ARU and later Warwick University, with full library rights, and he could download any papers I needed for reference, and I was able to get many papers published free of charge.
Almost overnight, the system changed as many journals switched to open-access mode. This means their contents are free to read, with the costs now put on the authors of the papers, and their universities pick up the tab. For many papers, this has led to a proliferation of names on each paper to spread the cost and give a maximum number of people the chance to add a paper to their CV, but it has shut many non-academics out of the system, for the costs are prohibitive. Galaxies is published in Switzerland and charges 1,500 Swiss Francs (luckily zero-rated VAT). Had it been accepted by the Royal Astronomical Society, the cost would have been £3,200, while the world’s most prestigious journals such as Nature now charge over $10,000 for the privilege of publishing a paper with them.
This has completely distorted the world of academic publishing as I can now no longer afford to write another paper. It has also induced a whole industry of copycat vanity publishers with low cost glitzy-sounding publications that bombard us with flattering requests for papers which will always be published. These pop-up journals are completely disregarded by the indexing engines, so are academically worthless.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Your comments are welcome - please add your thoughts!